Trade Bait

We knew they'd hit, but could the Sox starters hold it down?

The sights, and sounds, and smells of summer are in full swing, but it feels like Christmas!  Christmas in July, that is.  The Major League Baseball non-waiver trading deadline is under two weeks away, and it’s no secret that July 31st is one of my favorite days of the year.  It takes a lot to win a World Series Championship, and most teams don’t have all the pieces right at the outset.  The trading deadline allows the major players in the league to go out and get those missing pieces that they hope will put them over the top.  The coverage is always completely ridiculous, and now with most of the “insiders” using Twitter, this season promises to be even more in your face.  It’s exciting to follow along to see where the pieces land, which is why it’s so hard for me to say that the Sox need to stand pat.  Momentum can swing in a huge way after this day has come and gone, but as we approach this yearly shift in baseball, a warning: don’t sell the farm.

 

The Red Sox are in first place in the A.L. East, and show no signs of slowing down over the last three months of the season.  There are a number of positions that are producing at numbers that don’t quite live up to expectations, but we’re alright.  With a one game lead and 68 games to play in the season, the Red Sox will pick up major pieces without having to trade for anyone.  If you run down the roster, there are two positions that you could highlight as trouble spots for the Sox as they head down the stretch—starting-pitching and right field.

 

As we entered the season, the offense was supposed to be monstrous, and it has been.  So why mess?  Yes, JD Drew has been lackluster at best in right, but with Josh Reddick knocking the cover off the ball, we’ve got a nice platoon out there in right. The two big guns on the trade market, Carlos Beltran and Ryan Ludwick, wouldn’t provide enough of an upgrade to warrant a farm system fire sale, and there will surely be a piece that will pass through waivers later in the summer that Boston could use to spell Drew and Reddick at the 9thposition.  The Sox have scored more runs, have more extra base hits, and have the highest batting average in the majors.  They are who we thought they were, so let’s leave them be.  It’s the starting rotation that had all the question marks back in March.

 

Is Josh Beckett due for a comeback?  Which Clay Buchholz will we see to start the season?  Do Dice-K and Wakefield have anything left in the tank?  And finally, was the worst free agent pitching contract in Red Sox history signed by John Lackey?  Now that we’ve gone through two-thirds of the season, we can answer a number of those questions.  Yes, Beckett was due for a comeback, and he has been tremendous.  Buchholz isn’t quite as good as his break-out 2010 campaign may have shown, but when healthy, he may be the best number three starter in the league.  Dice-K is done, and Wakefield is spitting straight in the face of father time.  And yes, John Lackey is just plain terrible.  All of that said—the Red Sox don’t need to go out and get a starting pitcher.

 

When Lester and Buchholz come back from the DL, and it is my personal opinion that we shouldn’t see either of them back in the bigs for at least a month, it will be like they went out and got a true number one and a true number three.  Let’s not forget here people, Boston is in first place in the toughest division in the league.  So Theo, if you’re reading, give those guys some time to get themselves right, trust the team you have, and don’t mortgage the farm to get a starting arm come the deadline.

NFL Roundup: The Eli Effect

Big news from the NFL in week 9.  In the NFC, Big D used its D to stop the Eagles and their two game win streak and take over the top spot in the East.  New Orleans stayed perfect but started very slowly against the Panthers who need to very seriously look at who they want under center.  Arizona absolutely wrecked the Bears in Chicago behind monster days from Kurt Warner and Larry Fitzgerald.  The Bucs got off the snide and laid a big hit on the reeling Packers.  And in the battle of who cares the Seahawks came from behind to beat the Lions.

The bigger storylines, however, were in the AFC.  The Patriots continued their dominance over the Fins and put the smack down on the wildcat.  The Bengals proved they’re for real against a stumbling Baltimore team that looked in the beginning of the season like it was going to run away with the division.  The Colts barely got by the Texans and remain undefeated going into week ten for the third time this decade.  And the Chargers shocked the Giants in the final minutes and won by a point in the Meadowlands.  Leading up to the San Diego/New York game the media made a huge deal about the draft in 2004. What I’m wondering is if anyone was as appalled about Eli’s refusal to play for San Diego as I was.  You can make an argument five years later that both teams were winners.  Eli led the Giants to their first Superbowl since 1990 in 2007 when they beat the Pats and San Diego ended up with two additional draft picks which turned into perennial pro-bowlers Shawn Merriman and Nate Kaeding.  What stands out to me was the reasoning behind Eli’s refusal.  He simply didn’t want to play in the same conference as his brother.  Eli and his agent crafted that deal to get him out of the AFC because it was Peyton’s turf.  He was the top dog, the Colts were coming off a 12-4 season where big bro threw for over 4,000 yards and 29 touchdowns.  Eli knowing that he couldn’t compete and fueled by the Indy/San Diego rivalry simply stated that he wouldn’t sign.  He even did an interview AFTER HE WAS DRAFTED saying that he was hoping for a trade.  Now let me get this straight.  You are a highly touted college quarterback, you get picked first overall, you are about to sign a contract that will make you the highest paid rookie in league history, but you won’t sign with the team that drafted you because you don’t want to have to put up numbers against your big brother?  Well I got news for you buddy…it doesn’t matter where you play, you’re a Manning and you’re gonna be compared against other Mannings for the rest of your life!

It’s impossible to say what the league would look like now if Eli had in fact signed with the Chargers and Rivers had ended up with the Giants, but I think you can make a major argument that Rivers would have the ring right now and Eli would be sulking his way through another early playoff exit in San Diego.  Intangibles aside (and I do grasp the importance of leadership), Rivers is the better quarterback.  He has a higher career passer rating, he’s thrown for more yards and fewer picks, and if you get real crazy and start looking at splits Rivers, has him beat there too.  He’s got a higher completion percentage and passer rating in the final two minutes of games and he can make the big throw as evidenced by his 56% completion rate on throws of 20 or more yards.  Put simply, Rivers isn’t winning in San Diego because he has greater competition.  Every year the playoffs go through New England, Indy and Pittsburgh, because these teams are perennial powerhouses.  They have terrific personnel in the front office, they are coached well and their players are seasoned winners.  When Brady and Peyton start to slow in their ripe old age, we are going to be set up for some incredible Ben Roethlisberger/Phillip Rivers match-ups, and Rivers will get his ring. They will be the best two quarterbacks in the AFC, but right now there are just two many good QB’s standing in the way.

When you come back to last night’s game in New Jersey you are left with one thing: leadership.  Eli has always been labeled the leader, while Rivers has been called the distraction, but last night, under pressure and faced with a long field, Rivers crafted a masterful drive, going 80 yards and completing 6 of 8 passes.  He ran the offense through a no huddle two minute drill and threw the winning score to Vincent Jackson with 21 seconds left on the clock, leaving Eli no time to get his team into field goal range.  He showed poise, guts, a killer instinct, and I think what is sometimes lost with Rivers: passion.  He gets his team fired up, and yes, he can sometimes run his mouth which makes him a target, but more importantly it takes the pressure off of his teammates.  This is what I think makes him a good leader.  He knows what his team needs and how to get it.   At the end of the day, Rivers was there, with a lightning bolt on his helmet, leading his team to victory.

The Mission Statement

If the Red Sox won the World Series but no one was there to see it, did it happen?  Picture this.  Keith Foulke is on the mound for the Red Sox, it’s game 4 of the 2004 World Series in St. Louis.  Edgar Renteria steps into the box with a 1-0 count. He takes the next pitch and hits a knubber back to the mound.  Foulke snares it; he is so stunned and excited that he hesitates to throw on to first.  He takes a couple steps towards the bag and flips underhanded to Doug Mientkiewicz.  That’s it.  The Red Sox have just won their first World Series title in 86 years.  BUT! The stands are empty, there are no camera crews, no flash bulbs, no Joe Buck trying to capture the emotions of hundreds of thousands of Boston fans.  It’s just a bunch of guys pouring champagne all over each other in the middle of a baseball field.  Doesn’t sound right, does it? So what conclusion do we draw from this? We face facts: it’s a fans game.  And I’m not just talking about baseball.  The American sports industry would be absolutely nowhere without its fan base.

That one moment on October 27th, 2004 changed the lives of millions of people and sent a riptide through the sports world.  With an unlikely cast of characters, a sometimes wobbly manager, and a 3-0 hole to the Yankees in the ALCS, no one expected them to win.  But they did, and it was the fans who carried them through those last 8 games.  When Dave Roberts stole that base in game 4, we knew something special was about to happen.  On ANY other Red Sox team, in ANY other year, he gets thrown out and the season is over.  But he didn’t and the Sox pulled off one of the most incredible comebacks in the history of sports. And WE did it.  Am I biased?  You bet your ass I am.  The Red Sox are my team.  They have been since I came out of the womb.  I’ve followed them every season since I could comprehend the game.  We, as fans, want to believe that we are a part of this, that we can somehow affect the outcome and push our team to the next level.  We employ truly crazy superstitions, wear rally caps and scream until our lungs bleed, all in the hope that we get to see them in the playoffs. We pour our hearts and souls into these teams.   So why are we getting such a raw deal?  Professional sports are an industry.  I get it.  There is money to be made, and if you have the opportunity to make a buck, why wouldn’t you do it?  Ticket prices are climbing, the media frenzy is increasing, every Tom, Dick or Harry is writing a blog (ironic, isn’t it?) or doing a Podcast.  We are all trying to cash in.  All it’s costing us is our sports identity.

That’s where I come in.  I took a sports broadcasting class this summer led by the immortal Ed Ingles.  He brought in a cast of characters to impart some wisdom on breaking into the sports business.  And they all basically had the same advice: Don’t quit, practice practice practice, and lastly, write.  It was that last one that knocked me for a loop.  I never considered writing; I didn’t think I had the chops, but sports broadcasting is what I want to do.  It’s something I feel like I can be good at.  So what do you write about?  Who will read it?  I thought about this for a long time and I came to this.  Fans will read it.  And so, I will write about the fans.  How do we get that identity back?  Who will fight for it? I don’t have the answers, but I’m hoping to explore these questions, and with your help maybe we can figure something out, come to some sort of arrangement, either with the sport (whichever it may be) or with ourselves.

So what are we going to do here?  I’m glad you asked.  Of course we’re going to talk sports, because a real fan isn’t a fan without knowledge.  But this can be so much more than that.  Along with all those sports posts, on the first Friday of every month you’ll see a story about the fan experience.  We have lots to discuss; whether it be gambling, fantasy sports, announcers, TV blackouts, the disappearance of the NHL, the lack of soccer in America or just plain old ticket prices — we’re going to cover it all.  And I want your feedback.  Each monthly post will be sent along with all your comments, to someone who can make a difference.  For example, the post set for December is about the disappearance of the NHL.  After the lockout ended in 2005 it seemed like the league vanished from TV and sports news shows, but no one seemed to get angry and it continued to get worse.  Now they cover, maybe 10 games nationally all year.  In the 2008-2009 postseason you couldn’t even see the first three rounds on National TV! So, we send the letter along with all your comments to NHL Commissioner Gary Bettman in hopes that he’ll notice the millions of hockey fans aching for more coverage. Will it work? Who knows?  But it’s worth standing up for.  Sports mean so much to us, so why shouldn’t we fight back? The 2004 Boston Red Sox were underdogs just like the fans of today.  Everyone is counting us out, but maybe, just maybe, we can pull off an even bigger comeback.