Maybe I’m crazy. Maybe I’m completely and totally out of my gourd. Maybe I’m so wrong that it makes “The Decision” look like a good idea, but isn’t Kevin Youkilis important to the Boston Red Sox? This seems like an almost redundant question, doesn’t it? But if that’s truly the case, why is he being handled this way?
Youk has been playing through some pretty severe pain over the last ten days, as he contends with an ankle sprain of unknown severity. For some unclear reason, Terry Francona and the Sox bigwigs have been trotting him out to play third base in meaningless early June games. It was most evident in a game against the Milwaukee Brewers last week. The Red Sox All-Star hit a chopper up the first base line and as he started toward the base, he clearly pulled up and grimaced in pain. The following half inning, and every inning since, Youk has been out in the field playing a very difficult position that requires agility and a quickness on your feet that he clearly doesn’t have at the moment.
To his credit, and in form with his true competitive nature, he hasn’t let the ankle get the better of him. And perhaps that’s the reason that Francona has left him in games. But it just doesn’t make sense to have your clean-up hitter playing through pain in June! Let Youk sit for a couple games, and give one of the two Sox corner infield prospects a shot. Better yet, let BOTH of them have a chance.
Drew Sutton has performed more than admirably in his time with the big club, hitting .314 while slugging .514 and committing only a single error in 17 games. Then there’s Yamaico Navarro, who’s currently sitting on a .925 OPS in Pawtucket while playing the hot corner for the Sox.
Here’s my thought: Put Youk on the 15-day DL and call up Navarro. Insert Navarro against lefties, and Sutton against righties. The minor leaguer is hitting over .320 against southpaws this season, while Sutton is over .340 against righties. Hello! This thing on? Why risk further injury to one of your most important players, when you have two completely capable backups who could clearly benefit from playing time on the big league level?
I understand the argument that Youk is an integral part of the Red Sox lineup, and that he’s finally catching his stride after an excruciatingly slow start, but let me leave you with a couple more numbers to make my case. The 2010 Red Sox were 60-44 with Kevin Youkilis in the lineup, and 29-29 without him. The 2011 version will need to play better than .500 ball if they hope to stay ahead of a very talented Yankee team and a very resilient Tampa team. Can Theo and Tito really risk losing this guy? I say no, hot hitter or not.




